Monday, March 16, 2009

The Left
and a Woman's Severed Head

By Phyllis Chesler

Within hours of the news of Aasiya Z. Hassan's February 12th beheading, allegedly by her husband, Muzzamil Hassan, in Buffalo, American-Muslim organizations and individuals began a dirge bemoaning the existence of domestic violence. But thanks be to Allah, they affirmed, such violence exists among all faiths and ethnicities. Such family violence, they insisted, had nothing to do with Islam. Muslim leaders emphasized that honor killings were “anti-Islamic" or "un-Islamic," a holdover from "pre-Islamic times." They vowed to preach against it in the mosque. All well and good.

That Mr. Hassan beheaded his wife--well, that simply wasn't dwelled upon. Muslim religious feminist, Asra Nomani, and Irshad Manjie, both referred to the Buffalo beheading as an "honor killing" and despaired of the silence which still surrounded this form of domestic violence against Muslim girls and women. As Muslim women, they were not as squeamish about condemning violence against Muslim women by Muslim men and by Islamic culture.

Zarqa Abid, a soulful-sounding religious Muslim woman claimed that her cousin was once married to this same Hassan, and she denounced Hassan as a "monster." Abid also criticized the Islamic community for having refused to listen to her when she attempted to alert them to Hassan's criminal nature and deeds. Instead, they shunned her and continued to shower him with their money and to honor him.

Saleemah Abdul-Ghafur, a Muslim author and activist, said that "there is so much negativity about Muslims (this beheading) sort of perpetuates it. The right wing is going to run with it and misuse it. But we've got to shine a light on this issue so that we can transform it."

Imam Mohamed Hagmagid Ali, of Sterling, Virginia, vice-president of the Islamic Society of North America, said that "violence against women is real and cannot be ignored."

Nevertheless, Muslim organizations are relatively silent about this atrocity, given how vocal they usually are when Islam or Muslims are involved. A Google search of CAIR and beheadings only revealed that CAIR had given the alleged murderer an award."

Alright, some Muslims are calling it an honor killing, most are insisting that it is not an honor killing and that it has nothing to do with Islam; some Muslims are admitting that, like other groups, Muslims also have a serious problem with violence against women. Progress, of sorts.

What did American feminists have to say? Well, I’m certainly one, and I have been on record a long, long time opposing Islamic gender and religious apartheid, both in Muslim lands and in the West. I write about this subject weekly, often daily. Nonie Darwish, a Muslim-born Palestinian-American feminist, has condemned Sharia law as dangerous to women and other living beings. Now, for the first time, an American non-Muslim feminist has joined us.

On February 13, 2009, Marcia Pappas, the President of NOW-New York State, hit the ground running. She was quoted world-wide, even as far away as India. Pappas bravely asserted that the Buffalo beheading was a domestic violence murder that smacked of terrorism and jihad. The February 16, 2009 NOW-New York State press release quoted her as saying:

And why is this horrendous story not all over the news? Is a Muslim woman's life not worth a five-minute report? This was, apparently, a terroristic version of "honor killing," a murder rooted in cultural notions about women's subordination to men. Are we now so respectful of the Muslim's religion that we soft-peddle atrocities committed in its name?...What is this deafening silence?

And exactly what do orders of protection do? Was Aasiya desperately waving the order of protection in Muzzamil's face when he slashed at her throat? Was it still clutched in her hand when her head hit the floor? You of the press, please shine a light on this most dreadful of murders. In a bizarre twist of fate it comes out that Muzzamil Hassan is founder of a television network called Bridges TV, whose purpose it was to portray Muslims in a positive light. This is a huge story. Please tell it!

Alas, other than Pappas, and the feminists who supported her privately, most feminist leaders either attacked Pappas or remained silent.

News of the beheading became public the evening of February 12, 2009. Eight days later, on February 20, 2009, more than a week after NOW-NY State President Pappas began talking to the media, and four days after Pappas released a press release, President of the National Organization for Women, Kim Gandy, finally published a column in which she stated that the beating of pop music star Rihanna is every bit as bad as the beheading of Aasiya Z. Hassan. Or the assassination of Benazir Bhutto.

Gandy joins many of the Muslim groups in failing to differentiate the difference between a terrible, humiliating beating, (Rihanna), and being stabbed many times and then beheaded while you are, quite possibly, still alive, perhaps even conscious.

Yes, I agree, and I share Gandy's concern: Domestic violence against women is an epidemic. Although we have laws against it, police officers and judges ready to arrest and prosecute, as well as (too few) shelters available for those intended victims who manage to escape--still, we have not managed to abolish the scourge of domestic violence. Gandy is, understandably, frustrated.

Many women, (the statistics vary), are killed by their intimate partners. Amy Siskind, at The Daily Beast, tells us that "Sadly, this type of tragedy is hardly unusual in our country, where each and every day three or more women are murdered by their husband or boyfriend. In fact, statistics tell us that in the ten days since Aasiya died, 30 or more women in America have been murdered by their husband or boyfriend. The attention on this case comes as a result of the gruesome way in which Aasiya was murdered—torture and then decapitation—and what a beheading symbolically means."

Yes, I agree. However, Gandy and her supporters still refuse to consider that Muslim women and immigrant women in general probably face much greater danger, both in terms of being beaten and being killed than do non-Muslim women; that Muslim women in Muslim countries are prey, targets, human sacrifices, every single day; and that if we do not stop the forces of jihad that are headed our way that many more women will be beaten, veiled, and killed both at home and on the street.

Feminist women. Educated women. Christian and Jewish women. Yes, even me and Kim Gandy.

Gandy rejects focusing on Aasiya Z. Hassan's beheading because it might play into the hands of conservative "racists;" it might lead to "profiling." Wait a minute. NOW has conducted a serious campaign against religion, mainly against Christianity and Judaism. Why the sudden respect for Islam, a religion which is, in reality, not a religion at all but is rather, a totalitarian political ideology which has undergone no evolution for 1400 years and which is dangerous to women and other living beings?

Gandy fears that we might only focus on Aasiya's beheading or even on Rihanna's beating as entertainment, escape, lured by such sensational or celebrity cases. It's possible, but, perhaps it is equally possible to learn from such cases precisely because they've grabbed our restless attention spans.

Let me repeat: Apples are not oranges. Domestic violence is not femicide. Let’s be careful not to mix the two up. And, western-style domestic violence/femicide does not often end with an Islamic-style beheading. I am saying that we must make these distinctions, not be blinded by political correctness.

For those American feminists and Muslim-Americans who still insist that beheadings and domestic violence/femicide against Muslim girls and women has absolutely, definitely, positively, nothing to do with Islam or Muslims: I dunno. Ask Nonie Darwish, Ayaan Hirsi Ali, Wafa Sultan, Robert Spencer, Geert Wilders, read Nonie's recent book Cruel and Usual Punishment, about the nature of Sharia law and Muslim women. My God, talk to Muslim feminist dissident-activists like UK-based Maryam Namazie, or the group “Muslims against Sharia Law” which I have now joined.

Kim Gandy: Please, I implore you, read what I've written about Islamic gender apartheid and its penetration of the West in The Death of Feminism. Read what I've written about this Buffalo case, HERE, HERE, HERE, HERE and HERE.

Yes, domestic violence exists everywhere, both in America and on every other continent. But it is not normalized nor is it glorified everywhere. In the West, it is now criminalized and increasingly prosecuted, with imperfect but increasing success. In Pakistan, where Mr. Hassan comes from, it rarely is. In Pakistan, girls and women are still decapitated by the Arabized Taliban, buried alive, routinely beaten in childhood and in marriage, (yes, and while they are pregnant); women are gang-raped--and when they legally protest, threatened with death. Women who want a divorce are shot, even in their feminist lawyer's offices.

Muzzamil "Mo" Hassan's heart and mind remains in the East, in Pakistan. His body remains in custody in Buffalo, charged with second degree murder. Until or unless "torture" can be proved, he is eligible to be tried only for second-degree murder. In my article, “A “Cultural” Offense/Defense—But For the Prosecution. Some Thoughts for the Prosecutor of the Buffalo Beheading,” at Pajamas, I have suggested that the prosecutor consider that Mo Hassan was completely in control.

Hassan selected the weapon or weapons. He planned this beheading. He was not out of control when he stabbed and beheaded his wife. He was controlling the situation in a Pakistani male Muslim kind of way: By decapitating the woman, who had once been his wife, who had turned uppity enough to dare to eject him from his own home and who planned to keep his children. Hassan may have been living in America for more than thirty years but he still remains a Pakistani Muslim male through and through. Beating a wife is the "normal" way to relate to her. Killing her for being disobedient, in his mind, was what she deserved.

Links worth your time

A S/H Public Service Notice

Domestic "Violence" Hotline!

1-800-799-SAFE (7233)
1.3 Million American Women Each Year
Are Physically Abused by their
Husbands or Boyfriends!

Get Help ~ Call 911 ~ Report it

(Or Call Above D.V.H. Hotline, Now!)

The Wisest Mind Has Something Yet To Learn!




Note: About C.A.I.R., The Council of American-Islamic Relations Chairman, Omar Ahmed has stated:

"Islam isn't in America to be Equal to any other faith, but to be DOMINANT! The Koran should be the Highest Authority in America, and ISLAM the only Accepted Religion on Earth."

(Is that clear enough for you, bunky?)

Such an arrogant boldness from a high Muslim authority (our guest) has earned him a swift kick in the derriere, and a one-way ticket back home to Saudi-Arabia.


It's among the Greatest of Mysteries how our Loud, Proud, and Strutting 'Savior-faire' Critics can receive any joy in the meek acceptance of such rude behavior.

The French Napolianic Legal Systems should be prepared for some significant and radical the hands of these brutal "religious" bullies!


Anonymous said...

Amen, Brother Reb!

I'd rather put my gold tooth, and 10% tithe (or dhimmi-tax) on a 90-to-1 long-shot with wrapped legs, and a fat jockey, in the Kentucky Derby!

^*^$$$$^*^ bye, bye

Tally-ho, y'all. Yer pal, Roger

Anonymous said...

Snake Hunters is a man!

I just found this site. My sister was an abused wife. Thanks for publishing this insane cruelty, and thanks also for the domestic violence hotline number under your links.

More people should know it, write it down in an address book & TALK about it!

It's Sickening!!!

1-800-789-SAFE, I'll spread the word to my friends at my school.

Carol, from Lakeside, Tennessee


Thanks Carol,

The cowardly story of the demeaning and subjugation of our women and young girls is not new; it dates back in part to 7th century Islam, and the ancient Sharia Law! It's shameful.

Your deliberate placement of several duplicate Domestic Violence Hotline Ads {with the 1-800 Number} can be a life-saving gesture! Also, on Food Market Bulletin Boards, and at your school; plus in Service Clubs & Church Meeting Halls.

Bloggers should think about it.

Another great method of widely disseminating this vital message is the Internet; your personal eMail Contact List can be a very effective way of helping others.



Note To New Viewers:

Mr. Mohamed Fadly is an old and valued blogger-friend, an Egyptian, and a young student of Sharia Law, and we have engaged in some interesting conversations for over a year.

Recently his Open Forum Weblog has suffered a "corrupting influence" which forced this Snake-Hunter to reluctantly withdraw from his site, although he is certainly welcomed here.

My main concern with this fine young fellow is his "micro-focus, zoom-in mentality" on the Palestine Vs Israel Conflict, to the exclusion of all other violence against the stoning of women in that culture, the beheadings, and cruel suicidal bombings around the world.

Mohamed does have an interesting blogsite that I would not hesitate to recommend to all.

Just Click > MOHAMED FADLY < at the bottom of our Links...and you are in Egypt...where you may type a thoughtful comment. reb


IF anyone doubts the high esteem I hold for my friend Mohamed Fadly,
I want them to know that I have
really great framed photos (2) on computer desk of (a) Mohamed that I took from his profile page, standing in a fruit orchard (that I've enlarged) and the other one of eldest daughter, myself and son-in-law with the date 5/18/95.

(I surely did look younger in that one!!!) Fourteen years just zipped by us FAST! reb

Anonymous said...


Democratic Senate Majority Leader
Senator Harry Reid wants to spend
$8,000,000,000 of our taxpayer dollars to construct a high-speed
rail-line from Disneyland.... (Anaheim, California) to SIN CITY,
Las Vegas, Nevada.

From Southern California's huge population center to the fabulous
casinos & girlie ranches, in less than a hour. (Now that's gutzy!)

Shame on you, Harry! And, Nancy Pelosi wants to Really Trash Our Immigration Laws, and turn major U.S. cities into "sanctuary places" for All Types of Illegals!
You can forget about I.C.E. your
Immigration Customs Enforcement!
The average hard-working voter families don't have a clue, until they read this Solid Info from the old 'Snake Hunter'...(So, stay tuned in folks!) reb

Mohamed said...

Check this, it may help in your post.


Thank you Mohamed,

I rather doubt that anything published by the discredited N.Y Times has significant value for any logical public forum.

See the last paragraph of "Axis Of Idiots" fine description of the New York Times, and its dying popularity here in America!

It has failed to provide accurate information, and is generally known today to be a 'propaganda rag' for the far-left political wiggies. You might find a more reliable source for the daily news.


Mohamed said...

Will this work?